How to Evaluate a Historic Structure Report or Building Survey
Before major work on an old industrial building, an owner often commissions a historic structure report or a condition survey. Neighbours, review boards and interested readers may later see these documents. This page offers a method for judging whether a report is thorough. It is general guidance, not a rating of any real report.
What a good report usually contains
The National Park Service describes the historic structure report as the main research and planning document for a historic building. Reports vary in scope, but a solid one generally includes:
- Developmental history: when the building was built, how it changed, and the evidence for each date, such as permits, maps, photographs and physical clues in the fabric.
- Physical description: structure, materials, and features room by room or elevation by elevation.
- Condition assessment: what is failing, how badly, and why. A good report links each problem to a cause, such as a blocked gutter behind a wet wall.
- Significance: which parts of the building matter most and why.
- Treatment recommendations: what should be done, and in what order, usually framed by one of the four treatments in the Secretary of the Interior's Standards.
Criteria for judging the report
| Question | Good sign | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Are dates backed by evidence? | Each date cites a map, record or physical clue | Round dates with no source |
| Was the whole building inspected? | Roof, basement and inaccessible areas noted, including what could not be reached | Only the street front is described |
| Are causes identified? | Damage is linked to water, movement or past repairs | Symptoms listed with no explanation |
| Is significance explained? | Features ranked with reasons | Everything called "historic" equally |
| Are recommendations proportionate? | Repair first, replace when needed, with reasons | Blanket replacement of windows or masonry |
| Is authorship clear? | Authors and their roles stated | No names or qualifications given |
Reading industrial reports in particular
Reports on breweries and factories should explain the process the building served, because that process explains its form. Why is the brewhouse tall? Why are there openings through the floors? Why is the cellar so deep? A report that describes a gravity brewhouse only as "a six-storey brick building" has missed the point. Look also for attention to machinery remains, rail spurs and yard surfaces, which are easily overlooked.
The Historic American Buildings Survey and Historic American Engineering Record collections at the Library of Congress are useful benchmarks: their measured drawings and written histories show what careful recording looks like. Compare a local report with a HABS or HAER file for a similar building and the difference in depth will show.
To check who wrote a report and whether they hold real qualifications, see who can call themselves a preservation architect. For judging finished projects, see the seven criteria for adaptive reuse.
Sources
- National Park Service, Preservation Brief 43: The Preparation and Use of Historic Structure Reports.
- Library of Congress: HABS/HAER/HALS collection.
- Texas Historical Commission: guidance on historic resource surveys.